Skip to main content

Monuments: Are they Truly Monumental?

Over the past couple of weeks, I’ve been learning and discussing about monuments in class. Reading numerous perspectives on the effectiveness of monuments, I can’t stop thinking; at what point does monument simply serve as a tourist attraction? Generally speaking, monuments were constructed to honor a historically significant person, or event. The Vietnam Veterans Memorial, a deep incision into the earth, a monument made one with nature, not in place of it. When one visits the touching site, they recognize the mirrored walls with names plastered. Do they stop to contemplate the barrier that stands between life and death? Or does the reflective wall function only as a photo point? As someone who has visited the Washington Memorial, I can dishearteningly say, my experience of the monument is blurred by a rush of tourists attempting to catch the perfect photograph. Over time, the architecture loses emotional value as people gaze their eyes towards it for a couple minutes and stroll away. The site is a quick appeal because of its overwhelming popularity- and because of the historical significance or whatever. Due to these reasons, I’ve come to dislike the city-centered location of many monuments. More visitors increases awareness of not only the monument, but the person or event itself. However, a secluded area offers what a city doesn’t; peace. A quality that naturally prompts a chance to stop and think. These days, I find that appreciation is often undervalued. Just a few minutes of extra time and reflection with the absence of a camera, is what I believe, to create a true monumental experience at the sight of a monument. 



Comments

  1. Divya DwarakanathSeptember 10, 2023 at 6:23 AM

    I agree wholeheartedly with your point about the Washington Memorial teeming with tourists. I visited it recently as well, and it wasn't as impactful as I had expected it to be. The height was imposing and the structure itself was really interesting to look at, but I didn't have much time to truly appreciate the sight because so many people were standing in front of it for so long when trying to get a photo of it. The space for reflection is lost when the monument becomes a tourist attraction.

    ReplyDelete
  2. DhrutiSeptember 10, 2023 at 8:18 AM

    I completely agree with your perspective. Memorial and Monuments often don't receive recognition for their true purpose. When monuments are located in more remote and contemplative areas, they gain significance, emphasizing the importance of the event or individual they commemorate. The ability to reflect on these monuments holds great value, yet it is frequently overlooked by many

    ReplyDelete
  3. bismaad kaurSeptember 10, 2023 at 12:42 PM

    I felt the same way when I visited the Berlin Wall this summer. I noticed that everyone immediately ran to the Wall in order to capture the perfect Instagram moment, instead of taking a moment to reflect on the history surrounding it. People used the area as a place to skateboard, and some even took pieces of it. This was extremely disheartening, and it definitely felt like the Wall was undervalued.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Dear Mr. Brown

Dear Mr. Brown,  My name is Arya Shah. I am seventeen years old, and a senior at Troy High School. I stumbled upon your poem, "Labor", initially out of reluctancy to check-the-box on what I thought was a labor intensive English assignment. However, I quickly became so engrossed into the poem and I forgot about the trivial work I was pulling my hair out for just a few minutes ago.  What I admire most about this poem is its ambiguity, and the unsettling atmosphere it leaves. While you begin ranting about "cuss[ing] cutting grass for women", and shift focus onto the women, I thought surely the poem would reveal a tender heart, or wholesome relationship with them that would romanticize the labor or at least blur its pain. But instead, it's so discomforting. Your force us readers to sit with the fact that "they're all dead" because it isn't only the labor that's painful, but also the love. I find that so hard to accept most times, and can't ...
Post a Comment
Read more

You're Nothing Like Me

You're fat. Your flabby  little  not so little actually, stomach rolls over your sari's petticoat. Pathetic.  You're ugly. Your eye bags are stripping away your youthful happy-go-lucky femininity which was an era long gone as your stretch marks remind you.   You're naive. Your hands are shedding their skin, bruised and burned because the kitchen is now engraved into your body. It's these hands with which you sign your children's papers so they can go on field trips and become people of their own, hands with which I once used to forge my own parent's signatures because I wanted to control my "destiny"—always written by someone else.   You're unwanted. I believed in Bollywood movies. I believed in a romanticized future, where a language barrier in a foreign country would mean they would laugh at my cute accent. Instead, they just laugh at you. They insult you and you can't even understand them. Your mannerisms aren't quirky, they're d...
Post a Comment
Read more

Cleanup On Aisle Seven!

I'd like to preface this blog by saying the following original poem is written in a style completely out of my comfort zone, so through my eyes as a poet, it appears a bit of a mess. But hey, "dissonance is a kind of sense" I guess.  Cleanup on aisle seven Where the neatly stacked pyramid of oranges has fallen Where people pass by Without giving a fly Spurting juice under their fashionably protected feet Now there’s a traffic jam on aisle seven Where someone bumps into a shelf of wine And when people point fingers at each others’ faults All that’s left to say is  It isn’t mine  So someone travels to aisle four And rips open a pack of paper towels to clean the floor  But the liquid has migrated far beyond control  Where now are also  Soggy unraveled rolls  Finally the janitor comes over But he slips and his head lowers  Now there’s blood everywhere  But who should care  To clean the aisles When the janitor is also the owner  I initia...
Post a Comment
Read more